Where To Swim When Not Between The Flags

For some people in the lifesaving world this blog will be controversial.

The thought of promoting anywhere else to swim at a beach except for between the red and yellow flags would be enough to make them turn grey.

The red & yellow flags mark out the safer area to swim and are patrolled by lifeguards and lifesavers.

The last Newspoll research into this area conducted by Surf Life Saving Australia found that 93% of people in Australia knew to swim between the red and yellow flags – so why don’t anywhere near that percentage actually swim between them?

Coastal safety statistics tell us that the majority of drowning deaths occur on unpatrolled beaches or during unpatrolled times – and that the largest demographic is males, specifically young invincible males.

Rip Currents also account for a large portion of drowning deaths and most people wouldn’t be able to spot one if they were walking into it. The first time beach-goers notice a rip on a beach is when they’re caught in one.

ACADEMY LESSONS:
Rip Currents

I don’t have any hard facts for this, but I would suggest these are the reasons people don’t swim between the flags:

  • Too many people in the area
  • Hate being corralled like sheep
  • Not on my local beach
  • Only up on the weekends
  • Flags not up early enough or late enough
  • Not on remote beaches visited
  • The best waves are outside them

So is it really that bad to swim outside the flags?

It really comes down to your ability to cope with the conditions on the day.

If you’re a strong swimmer, confident in the surf and you’re swimming with a mate (always a good idea whether between or outside the flags) then you can pretty much swim where you want to – within your limits of course.

On a beach that’s patrolled by lifeguards (or our volunteer lifesavers) it’s not the end of the world. You will be watched no matter where you are on the beach, however, the closer to the flags or lifeguard towers you are the better. You can’t bank your life on being seen, but you’ll have a better chance. And all this is assuming you can handle being whistled at by the lifesavers all day – not quite the beach experience you were after, I’d imagine.

On unpatrolled beaches you’re really swimming at your own peril. Chances are there is no professional help in easy response time, and if you got into trouble you’d be relying on your mates or your own ability.

Relying on your mates isn’t a great idea. Many would be rescuers become victims themselves, and you don’t want that on your conscience.

ARTICLE: How To Assist A Swimmer In Difficulty

So where do you swim when you don’t want to swim between the flags?

You’ll want to swim exactly where the flags would have been placed if there was a patrol operating – on a sand bar.

TAMARAMA BEACH: An almost perfect model of a sand bar with rip currents either side. This example also has a channel in front of the sand bar.

How do you locate a sand bar? This will be the area of the beach where it’s shallow and the waves are breaking consistently. The water here is more likely to be coming towards the shore as the waves bring water to the beach.

Remember, waves break in shallow water. So, the further out they’re breaking, and the longer the area of white-water the better – that means it’s a sand bank.

Conversely, if there’s a patch on the beach where waves are not breaking consistently, and there’s not much white-water around, then this is most likely the location of a Rip Current – so keep away.

This example is at Palm Beach at the start of the Palm to Whale Beach Ocean Swim. Can you spot the sand bars? What about the rip current?

You are likely to find a sand bar located between two rips. If you’re swimming on the sand bank and the water is sweeping you along the beach it’ll be pulling you towards a rip, so keep in the middle of the sand bar.

When you arrive at any beach you should observe the conditions for at least five minutes. This will give you a better picture of what the waves are doing over time and help you establish the cycle and consistency of the conditions.

Once you’re happy that you’ve spotted a sand bar (and the rips if you can) then you can go for a swim – but be careful.

Have fun and stay safe this summer – Know your Ocean Responsibility Code (except in this case you’ve chosen not to ‘Always swim at beaches patrolled by lifeguards’).

By Andre Slade
Andre is the founder of OceanFit & experienced ocean safety educator.

Comments
  • Guest June 06, 2012 at 12:09 pm

    I work in water safety and drowning prevention. In particular, my area of research is lifeguard vigilance and scanning. While your comments about rip currents are great, I do have some issue with your statement “On a beach that’s patrolled by lifeguards (or our volunteer lifesavers) it’s not the end of the world. You will be watched no matter where you are on the beach.”

    Thanks to a great deal of research on this topic, we now know it’s almost impossible for lifeguards to catch every incident. There are a number of reasons for this, including environmental (e.g. the effects of glare, heat, noise) and cognitive (e.g. fatigue, task characteristics, high volume of ‘information’ to interpret). The need for lifeguards to maintain high levels of vigilance during a repetitive task (scanning) ultimately leads to decreased subjective alertness, or an increased likelihood they will miss critical signals.

    In addition, perception blindness, which is when people fail to notice stimuli appearing in front of their eyes while preoccupied with another visual task (e.g. scanning swimmers between the flags), means lifeguards will sometimes miss incidents. This is difficult to combat, as perception blindness is your brain’s way of helping you deal with the massive amounts of visual information received.

    Several studies have also found it’s difficult to spot a person in trouble in choppy water if they are more than 2 metres away. This explains why it’s common for swimmers and surfers to be the first to recognize a person in distress.

    I think most lifeguards do a pretty good job of scanning, a task that’s a lot more difficult than most people realise. So while swimming between the flags isn’t a guarantee you’ll be seen if in trouble, it certainly enhances the likelihood.

    Reply

    • OceanFit June 08, 2012 at 2:36 am

      Thanks for the awesome insight into lifeguard scanning!

      You’re right, you can never fall into a false sense of security thinking someone has your back at any beach – patrolled or un-patrolled.

      This makes it even more important to learn survival swimming skills and to know your limits – if in doubt, stay out.

      Reply

POST A COMMENT

Comment as a Guest or Login


× three = 27

TWITTER
FACEBOOK
INSTAGRAM
WordPress SEO fine-tune by Meta SEO Pack from Poradnik Webmastera